I grew up in the Akron/Canton area and basically have lived here my entire life. I have never tried Mary Coyle's or Michael Trecaso's. I have been meaning to, and last week I did. It did not disappoint. Mary Coyle's is known for it's homemade ice cream and candies. Oh my goodness, the ice cream is incredible along with the hot fudge and fixings. I got the mint chocolate chip with hot fudge and peanuts. I wanted to lick the bowl it was that good!
I had to also try Michael Trecaso's, known for the pizza and they have all the other great Italian foods too. But, the pizza- also oh my goodness. It was cheesy, saucy and perfect. 5 out of 5 stars all around for this place. Go hungry and you will live 100% satisfied!!!